Rohit or Rahane? Rahul or Dhawan?

These are the much debated questions after India’s heartbreaking 72-run loss to South Africa at the New Lands in Cape Town. It was definitely India’s game with just 208 runs to victory in the 4th innings and yet India fell short by a long, long way!

Ajinkya Rahane is India’s best averaged batsman in overseas conditions in the current Indian squad was left out to make way for Rohit Sharma who has been brilliant at home off late against Sri Lanka. But can the current form at home alone be a criteria in getting selected in the overseas games?

Shikhar Dhawan was brilliant with the bat in 2017 but all his aggressiveness was against a single team – the out of form Sri Lanka. Did Dhawan really deserve his place in the side based on his performances solely against Sri Lanka?

The catching in the slip cordon is not good either with Shikhar Dhawan dropping Keshav Maharaj on naught (zero) in the 1st innings standing at third slip. Maharaj went on to make 35 runs in that innings but Dhawan accounted for just 34 runs in both the innings of the Test match!


Indian captain Virat Kohli spoke to the media after the 72-run loss in Cape Town and said that Rohit Sharma has been picked ahead of Rahane because of his current form with the bat. “We decided to go on with the current form. Rohit scored runs in the last 3 Tests and in the [limited overs] series against Sri Lanka,” said Kohli after a disappointing loss to South Africa in the 1st Test.

“We decided to go in with one combination. Current form was definitely the criteria,” added the Indian skipper.

Rahane Read Scoops

Proteas were a bowler-short in the 2nd innings (Dale Steyn was injured) and yet the Indian batsmen weren’t able to chase down the below-par target which even South African skipper Faf du Plessis admitted that he was a bit nervous to defend!

Questions to answer before 2nd Test:

Should a player be selected for overseas tours like South Africa based on the performances against the out-of-form Sri Lanka? And that too based on performances in home conditions? Does India really need a right-left partnership to open the innings?


We feel that some changes are certainly necessary in the Indian batting line-up to boost the team’s confidence after an unforgettable loss. After a flop show from the batsmen, the Indian fans have exploded on social media and demanded the inclusion of Lokesh Rahul & Ajinkya Rahane in the side ahead of the 2nd Test which starts from Saturday (Jan 13).

KL Rahul Read Scoops

Hope you have liked this article! Post your comments below. Also, stay tuned for more articles from me (Phaneendra Varma). Follow my Twitter handle (@Cric_Stat) for daily cricket stats!

About Phaneendra Varma 56 Articles
Cricket Fan. Follower of the Cricket game since 2003 World Cup!

1 Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*